A Proper Review of the Statistics in Lucy Letby’s Trial

It is well known that the statistics used to convict Lucy Letby at her trial were fallacious. The most notorious example being the roster chart which did nothing more than show she was present at certain times when she was present, yet was used to create a sinister connotation.

What has not been done so far as we can tell at least in the public domain, is a proper review of the statistics. To that end, I have recently been taking part in a project to do just that. Collaborating in this includes Peter Elston, who has done extensive work on the statistics of the case already, as well as three other collaborators (all UK-based) who wish to remain anonymous for the time being.

For the exact same reasons as shown in my earlier blog post, I was as certain as one can practically be that a proper statistical analysis of the case would in no way point towards guilt, and indeed that appears to be the case based on our preliminary findings. With that said, all involved are committed to publishing the results regardless of whether they work for or against Lucy. Our ultimate commitment is to the truth. Above all, contrary to what many pitchforkers would have you believe, if I ever found evidence pointing to a serial killer of children, I would promptly make it known to the relevant authorities. I’m not Ravi Jayaram after all!

In the rest of this blog post, I will summarise some key preliminary findings as well as provide some formal housekeeping concerning data protection on this project as required by law.

The Rise in Mortality at CoCH:

Our preliminary findings show that, even with a very prosecution-friendly model, the rise in mortality at CoCH neonatal unit from June 2015 to June 2016 was of a statistical significance one would expect to observe in around one unit per year in the country.

This comes when one accounts, at least in part, for the following factors:

  1. Number of IC patient days in a given period
  2. Uncertainty in the estimate for the mortality rate per IC patient day
  3. Interval length can be varied to produce the most statistically significant “spike” in mortality possible

Moreover, this model operates on the assumption that the hospital continued to perform just as well even in the face of a significant rise in IC days that CoCH was forced to cope with, most likely due to the maternity crisis in North Wales.

If one accepts the common-sense belief that the hospital would have struggled to cope with this increased burden, thus causing the per IC patient-day mortality rate to increase, then the chance of a rise in mortality will be substantially higher than our prosecution-friendly model suggests.

Our model also does not account for other factors. For example, Thirlwall showed that the number of infants with birthweights below <2000g increased during the June 2015 to June 2016 period, which one would expect to increase the chance of a spike in mortality even higher.

How was Lucy Letby Associated with so many Deaths?

This is the current part of the research we are focusing on developing the most, but we have a few preliminary observations.

Firstly, the number of patients in intensive care is substantially higher when Lucy Letby is on shift than when she is not. A potential confounder behind this was her status as the jointly most qualified nurse in her pay bracket. This likely meant that the cheapest way to staff the rota was to use Letby as much as possible for shifts with multiple patients in intensive care, for which she could be used with her QIS qualification, while using the less-qualified Band 5 nurses on shifts with only a single or no patient in intensive care. The fact that Letby was a young nurse and single likely meant she had greater flexibility allowing her to fit such a schedule.

Secondly, heterogeneity is a really important feature. The chance of a death occurring at a given time on the unit is not constant. It varies based on how many patients are present in intensive care at a given time, what their gestational ages and birthweights are, whether or not they are a multiple, whether or not the unit is understaffed at a given time, and any other comorbidities individual patients might have. If one assumes even a small amount of heterogeneity, the chance of an individual nurse being present for a large number of deaths rises dramatically. This is the same phenomenon as I observed in the case of Lucia de Berk, where even a small amount of heterogeneity, combined with correcting other fallacies, meant that the true probability of de Berk being present for the deaths she was at was 1 in 50, a far cry from the 1 in 342 million claimed at her original trial.

Of course, even a 1 in 50 event still implies that a nurse was unlucky to be present at many deaths. But in a country with thousands of nurses, hundreds of thousands in the case of England, you would expect this to happen to a large number of nurses quite regularly. Just as someone is statistically almost guaranteed to win the lottery somewhere, even if their individual chances of doing so are small, it is almost guaranteed that many nurses will be present for many deaths. It does not imply on its own that they were responsible for any wrongdoing.

We would like to develop this work further by using data such as gestational ages and birthweight to account for some of this heterogeneity and obtain a more precise estimate of the chance of a nurse being present for some minimum number of patient deaths.

Lessons for Use of Statistics:

There are several key lessons that should be learned from this story.

One key lesson is that, when the decision around what analysis to do is based on the same data one is analysing, extreme caution must be exercised. Even subconsciously, one can use the data to perform an analysis decision aimed at achieving the very outcome one wants, while ignoring analysis approaches that do not achieve that outcome.

This issue is illustrated repeatedly throughout the case of Letby, including, but by no means limited to, the following:

  1. Defining “suspicious events”, “collapses” or “collapses leading to death” on the basis of whether Lucy was present there in the first place. It is known that at least 10 instances where it was initially thought a baby had been attacked or an otherwise “suspicious” event took place were dropped from the shift chart after Letby was found to be absent from the hospital at the time.
  2. Choosing the specific interval over which to analyse the rise in mortality on the basis of whether a rise in mortality happened to occur.

Another key lesson is that null events are extremely important to keep in mind. The death of 10 patients out of 10 is far more suspicious than the death of 10 patients out of 1000. If an unusual event is merely the result of there being many opportunities for it to happen, and it just occurred eventually at some point, then the fact an event might be rare does not imply that a rare cause must be responsible for it.

Courts seem to be extremely poor at grasping this critical concept. This is evident when the court looked only at collapses when Lucy Letby was present while ignoring other “suspicious events” after it turns out Lucy was never there catastrophically fails to grasp this key principle. It’s rather like evaluating the performance of the Dutch National Football Team by looking at only the matches they have won, while ignoring their defeats like the 2010 World Cup final.

One potential reason courts are so poor at understanding this critical concept is that courts usually handle events that are inherently rare, such as a murder where there’s no dispute a crime has occurred and the only debate is who the perpetrator was. However, determining from observational data whether an exceptionally rare cause even happened at all (such as a serial killer nurse) is a very different task. The more one looks into the case of Lucy Letby, the more one appreciates how ill-equipped courts are for handling these sort of cases.

Data Protection Housekeeping:

The law on data protection in both the UK and EU requires one to fulfil a number of key principles when handling personal data. One of those is transparency, and it is in that spirit that I provide some data protection housekeeping here.

Rights of Data Subjects:

Any data subject is welcome to contact me, including via email, if they want any further information or clarification regarding the project, and we shall endeavour to answer all queries.

Data Subjects ordinarily have a number of rights, the full details of which can be obtained on the UK Information Commissioner’s Office website. See the following link for further details: A guide to individual rights | ICO

These rights include the following:

  1. Right of Access: The right to access and receive a copy of one’s personal data.
  2. Right of Rectification: One has a right for any inaccurate personal data about oneself to be corrected
  3. Right of Restriction: One has a right to restrict how one’s personal data is used in certain circumstances
  4. Right to Object: One has a right to object to the use of one’s personal data, although this right does not apply for processing done under Article 6(1)(e) for reasons of public interest, a provision we rely on (see later for more details)
  5. Right of Erasure: One has a right to have one’s personal data erased in certain circumstances

It is worth noting that there can be restrictions on these rights. In particular, restrictions often apply when exercising the right would substantially impede the academic research we are conducting.

Data subjects also have a right to complain both to the data controller responsible for processing the data, as well as to the appropriate regulatory, in this case the UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO).

However, even though such a right to complain exists, we wish to emphasise that we want to work collaboratively with data subjects as much as possible and resolve any queries that they have. If a data subject identifies a flaw in our practices, we would like to work with them and remedy it wherever possible. We also would like the data to be processed in a way that leaves subjects genuinely assured that the use of their personal data in this research project will not result in any adverse effects against them, and we are more than happy to work with them as much as possible to achieve that outcome.

General Public Interest:

There are numerous reasons why this research is so vital, and why we believe it is substantially in the public interest to do:

  1. To help ascertain what really happened at the Countess of Chester Neonatal Unit. In particular, we hope our research can help contribute to ascertaining whether or not Lucy Letby has been the victim of a miscarriage of justice, or if she is indeed guilty of the crimes she has been convicted of.
  2. To provide lessons in the use and misuse of statistics in the legal setting, regardless of whether Lucy Letby has been the victim of a miscarriage of justice.
  3. If it does contribute towards showing Lucy Letby was the victim of a catastrophic miscarriage of justice, there will likely be huge implications for the criminal justice system
  4. Thirlwall has proposed wholesale changes to the NHS, including the abolition of no-blame culture, which will likely make patient care worse. This would be bad enough in any event; it is even worse if it is based on something that never happened. This research can help determine whether that is indeed the case.
  5. Given the public debate around the case of Lucy Letby is likely to continue for the foreseeable future in any event, we hope this research can help make that debate healthier and better informed.

While the practitioners of this research make no secret that we come into it with a very strong prior that Lucy Letby has been the victim of a miscarriage of justice, we do wish to emphasise that our ultimate commitment is to the truth.

Both under academic standards and human standards, we will not hesitate to publish our research if at any time it were to point against our prior belief and suggest Lucy Letby was indeed guilty of the crimes she was convicted of. We believe the public interest behind our research goes far beyond the fate of one person, and our commitment to publishing our findings no matter the result reflects that belief.

Specific Data Used:

The data used in this project will include the nurse’s shift chart, as well as admissions data for 9 out of the 13 months between June 2015 and June 2016. Unfortunately, we don’t have data for the four months where there was no indictment event. The admissions data was obtained by Peter Elston from Lucy’s defence barrister, Mr Mark McDonald and, for the infants admitted to the neonatal unit in those 9 months, contain their gestational ages, birthweights, when they were in the unit and with what category of care (intensive care, high dependency care, special care, normal) on a given day.

How the Data will be Used:

The use of this data is necessary to compare the mortality at CoCH relative to gestational age and birthweight to that of other known environments. The admissions data also allows us to calculate the total IC days over a given time interval, which is also necessary for some of our modelling.

We may require using the data subsequently to develop models around the association of a particular nurse’s presence with mortality, such as discrete time survival models. Should this need arise, we will make sure not to publish anything that could theoretically be reverse-engineered to obtain the original dataset.

It goes without saying this contains very sensitive data, including what GDPR regards as special category data. We therefore make clear at once that nothing will be published that could possibly be used to identify any patient. For example, any graphical displays will be scrambled appropriately to ensure they cannot be reverse-engineered to obtain the original dataset. Nothing will be published pertaining to any individual patient either.

The only reason we use this data is to research the spike in mortality in the Countess, as well as the reasons behind a nurse being present for many of the deaths. In no way will the data be used to make any decision about any individual patient, and, given the summary nature of what we publish, nothing released will have any prospect of doing so either.

Legal Basis for Processing Data:

Formally, the legal bases on which we use this data are article 6(1)(e) (task in the public interest), article 6(1)(f) (legitimate interests) and article 9(2)(j) (archiving, research and statistics) together with section 1 paragraph 4 of Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA). The legitimate interests are the same as those expressed earlier as to why this research is so important, and they form the same reasons as to why we consider this research to be in the general public interest, a key requirement under Article 9(2)(j).

If necessary, at certain points to ensure the completion of the project, we also rely on Schedule 2, paragraph 27 of DPA (the research purposes exemption) and, if necessary, Schedule 2, paragraph 26 of DPA (the academic expression exemption). In particular, with respect to the latter, because the project is done with a view to publishing academic material and we believe that doing so is in the general public interest, this allows us to use the academic expression exemption whenever we reasonably believe a given provision to which the exemption is eligible to be applied would otherwise be incompatible with the academic purpose behind this research.

Why I am more than 99.99% certain that Lucy Letby is innocent

I use Bayes theorem: posterior odds equals prior odds times likelihood ratio. For an introduction, please read this nice blog post https://entropicthoughts.com/bayes-rule-odds-form

I use this rule, Bayes’ rule, repeatedly, each time taking account of another part of the evidence. It is named for Thomas Bayes, a presbyterian minister and mathematician, who was interested in using it to find a mathematical proof of the existence of God. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bayes

The likelihood ratio for the question at hand, based on some part of the evidence, is the ratio of the probabilities of that part of the evidence under the two competing hypotheses. More precisely, one uses the conditional probabilities of that fact given previously incorporated evidence.  We have to start somewhere and we start by describing two alternative hypotheses and our probabilities or degrees of belief or personal betting odds for those two hypotheses, before further evidence is taken into account. 

Let’s start with the news reports of a police investigation of a possible killer nurse at a neonatology unit in the UK; the investigation being triggered by a disturbing spike in the death rate on that unit.

I think that in the last fifty years there simply hasn’t been been a case in the UK of a killer nurse on a neonatal ward, except possibly the case of Beverley Allitt. One might argue that there do exist doubts as to the safety of her conviction, or one might argue that there can have been serial killer nurses who completely evaded detection. Did Alittit work in an intensive care unit? I also think that in recent years, every year has seen a scandalous calamity in a UK neonatal ward, leading to avoidable deaths of quite a few babies. So a priori: the relative chances of a killer nurse being responsible for the spike, or simply poor care, is in my estimation 50:1 in favour of poor care in a failing hospital unit rather than activity of a killer. If you disagree, give me your arguments for both those rates and hence their ratio. If you would like to take a different starting point, try that. Eg, what is the chance a random nurse is a serial killer? At some point one will have to use the information that this was a neonatal unit and one will have to take account of the “normal” rate of deaths on the unit. I think my choice is reasonably specific. One could argue that the prior odds should be 10 to 1, or 100 to 1, instead of 50 to 1. I expect that most people will at least agree that killer nurses on neonatal units are very rare, disastrously poor care on a neonatal unit in the UK is not rare at all.

So we are back in 2017 and hear the news and rightly we should be sceptical that there really is a case here. But clearly there are grounds to investigate what is the cause of that spike, and maybe there is more information which the police already have.

Then, many years go by. A particular nurse is detained for questioning in two successive years; and finally arrested in a third year. Two more years go by (Corona). At last, a trial begins. It turns out that roughly seven years of police investigation has uncovered no direct evidence at all (neither medical evidence, toxicological evidence, witness testimony or CCTV recordings, finger prints or DNA) of unlawful action by the nurse who has been under intensive investigation all that time. And not just no evidence against that nurse – no direct strong evidence of malevolent activity by anyone. 

One might want to argue that the insulin evidence is strong toxicological evidence. We could argue about that for a long time. Even if one or two babies were given unauthorised doses of insulin there is no direct proof that Lucy Letby did that herself. There is the possibility of accidental administration (twins in adjacent cots). The argument that Lucy did administer insulin seems to have been that we know at some point she carried out other murderous attacks and it is unlikely that there were two murderous nurses working in the unit. But why do we believe there are murderous nurses working on the unit? This argument can only be made after hearing all the other evidence in the case.

So we have to estimate the probability of a 7 year police hunt for evidence of murder by a particular nurse finding no direct evidence of any malevolent activity at all by anyone, if Lucy Letby actually was innocent, and if she truly was a serial killer. In my opinion ,what we actually observed is much more likely under the innocence hypothesis than under the guilty hypothesis. If she truly is innocent the chance of finding powerful directly incriminating evidence must be rather small; if she truly is a serial killer then it must be unlikely that that no baby can be definitely proven to have been murdered or attacked. I guess the two probabilities of no hard evidence to be 95% and 5% respectively. These are probabilities of 19/20 and 1/20 respectively, so a likelihood ratio of 19. I’ll be a bit more cautious and call it 10.

We already had odds of 50:1 in favour of innocence. We have a likelihood ratio of 10:1 in favour of innocence, having learnt that police investigation uncovered no strong and direct proof of malevolent harm to any baby. The odds on Lucy being innocent are therefore now 50 times 10, or 500 to 1.

Let’s now bring in the evidence from psychology. Are there reasons to believe Lucy is a psychopath? Which surely she must be, if she is a serial killer of babies in her care. It seems there is no reason at all to suspect she is a psychopath. I think that there very likely would be strong independent signs of psychopathy in her life history if she really is a serial killer, but obviously not so likely if she is completely innocent. [Clearly she could be both a psychopath but did not actually harm or try to harm any baby. I don’t think this is an interesting hypothesis to explore. I will also not pay attention to the Munchhausen by proxy idea, that she was trying to attract the attention of an older male doctor. All the evidence says that he was more romantically interested in her, than vice versa.]

Put the likelihood ratio at 2, ie twice as likely to see no evidence for psychopathy if innocent, than if a serial killer. Actually I think it should be closer to 10. We should ask some psychologists. Lucy Letby did not sadistically kill little animals when she was a child. By all accounts, she was a dedicated nurse and cared deeply for her work.

We were at 500 to 1 for innocence. Factor in a likelihood ratio of 2 for psychological evidence. Now it’s 1000 to 1. But we are not done yet.

Next, I would like to take account of the statistical evidence that the spike in deaths is quite adequately explained by the acuity of the patients being treated in those 18 months. I would say that this is exactly what we would expect if Lucy is innocent but very unlikely if she’s a serial killer. I think this hypothesis is very adequately supported by published MBRRACE-UK statistics, and what we know about the acuity of the babies in the case. We know why acuity went up in around 2014 and we know why it went down midway in 2017. The spike seems to have been caused by hospital policy which was being made and implemented by the consultants on that unit. They should have expected it.

Say a likelihood ratio of 10. That brings us to 10,000 to 1 she’s innocent; a posterior probability of 99.99%. I haven’t yet brought in the facts of an investigation driven by tunnel vision and coached by doctors who, as we now know, were making quite a few deadly mistakes themselves. I haven’t brought in yet the innocent explanation of the post-it note. In my opinion, the post-it note is powerful evidence for innocence; it makes absolutely no sense under the hypothesis of guilt. The irrelevance of the handover notes and the notations in her diary. Facebook searches? Her alleged lies (about what she was wearing when she was arrested). Anything else?  

Anyway, I am now well above 99.99% sure that Lucy is innocent and since the press conference and the report of Shoo Lee and his colleagues, we can all be even more sure that that is the case. 

My LinkedIn conversation with Dewi Evans

This LinkedIn conversation started with me asking Dewi Evans to connect to me. I was amazed that he accepted. I guess my request contained a brief message too, but this is not recorded in my LinkedIn account. I suppose Dewi has it in an email sent to him from LinkedIn. It would be nice to see it.

Dewi – are you there, reading this?

  • Feb 3, 2024
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 11:46 AM
  • 11:46 AM Dear Richard. I’ve read your comments re the importance of statistics in court cases. I can’t comment on specific cases currently because of reporting restrictions.
    I would welcome discussing this with you, as it’s a matter that is worth exploring.
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 12:30 PM 
  • 12:30 PM I agree! I am looking forward to the reporting restrictions being lifted. Hope to talk to you within a year from now…
  • 12:32 PM Do take a look at the case of Lucia de Berk. The case is horrifically similar to that of Lucy Letby. I helped get her out of jail. Also an Italian nurse, Daniela Poggiali. I acted as expert on the applications to the CCRC of Ben Geen. I am sure he is innocent but UK criminal justice is nowadays badly tilted in favour of the prosecution.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 12:36 PM
  • 12:36 PM With a bit of luck reporting restrictions will be lifted after the end of the retrial due in June.
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 12:44 PM
  • 12:44 PM👍
  • 6:44 PM We have both been interviewed by Raj Persaud! https://rajpersaud.libsyn.com/Raj Persaud in conversation – the podcastsrajpersaud.libsyn.com
  • Feb 6, 2024
  • 7:03 AM I’m visiting Liverpool to give a lecture next week, dept of statistics. Will probably also check out Chester. Would you like to meet? I’m not interested in reporting restrictions. They are unfair and immoral. Science must not be stopped. Chester police sent Dutch police to my door in the night to intimidate me. This only made me speak out more loudly.
  • 7:21 AM Do you have an email address? I’d like to send you some links and materials
  • 8:11 AM By the way, reporting restrictions means reporters cannot write in newspapers about evidence supporting Lucy’s innocence. However, it allows the Daily Mail to publish week by week horrible stories about how evil she is, her cushy life in jail, her friendship with another killer … You and I are not reporters. There is no law against us exchanging information. You can tell me about medicine, I can tell you about forensic science. I’m sorry for you that you live in a police state. In the Netherlands there are also disturbing developments. The state is eroding civil rights. In the UK the process has got much further.
  • 8:12 AM Fortunately, many investigative reporters are working on the case and many scientists are working on the case. The dam is starting to crack and it won’t be long before it crashes down.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 9:37 AM
  • 9:37 AM No problem having a private discussion. But reporting restrictions are reporting restrictions and all that. I’ve no wish to contaminate due process. I’ve no idea re Daily Mail articles. Never read it (apart from the one where they covered the Letby story after speaking to me. My easy access email is xxxx@xxxxx.xxx
  • Richard Gill sent the following message at 10:48 AM
  • 10:48 AM Thanks for the email address! I do not wish to contaminate due process either. I wish to ensure due process. I can promise in advance of any discussion with you total confidentiality.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 10:48 AM
  • 10:48 AM Thanks Richard
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 11:37 AM
  • 11:37 AM Interesting development: the Mirror uses a *nice* photograph of #LucyLetby. Doesn’t call her a sadistic killer. And a leading barrister calls for “open justice”. Geoffrey Robertson KC said “Open justice is the principle that makes British courts the best in the world and judges should be more vigilant in protecting it”. They used to be the best in the world. Right now they are among the worst in the developed/free world. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/lucy-letby-anger-cowardly-doctors-32045213Fury as ‘cowardly’ docs and nurses who worked with Lucy Letby keep names secretmirror.co.uk
  • Feb 22, 2024
  • 6:56 PM You asked for all the deaths and all the collapses in the period January 2015 to July 2016. They gave you all the deaths but only collapses when Lucy was there. There must have been at least 50 collapses when she wasn’t on duty, given the acuity of those infants. You were lied to, you were used.
  • Feb 23, 2024
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 10:31 AM
  • 10:31 AM That is incorrect. I received information re numerous collapses. I separated them into those that were explained by the common causes- infection, haemorrhage etc and those that were not explained, ie suspicious. The name Lucy Letby was not known to me at the time.
    As for “at least 50 collapses” I don’t know where you got that figure from.
  • Richard Gill sent the following message at 10:54 AM   
  • 10:54 AM Interesting. Your story does not match the story one gets from other sources (for instance, the police themselves). I got my figure from several neonatologists and a similar figure from nurses with experience in neonatal intensive care. Secondly, “not explained” is not synonymous with “suspicious”. This confusion of words in the minds of on experts was exactly what led to the conviction of Lucia de Berk. I recommend you study it carefully!
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 11:17 AM
  • 11:17 AM Away this weekend. Back Tuesday.
    Content to engage post the appeal and retrial. Information from the police was all disclosed to the Defence presumably. Those are the rules.
    No idea which other neonatologists involved. 2 gave reports for the Defence. They were not called. That’s a Defence issue.
    Read the Lucia de Berk story via Wikipedia weeks ago.
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 11:35 AM    
  • 11:35 AM I know, the defence was useless. Scandalous. The newspapers were appalling. Social media too. This was not a fair trial.
  • 11:37 AM Lucy Letby was a whistleblower and got crushed by the NHS. Much better to put the blame on a killer nurse than on lax consultants and poor management. Focussed on cost cutting at the expense of patient care.
  •  11:51 AM Have a. nice weekend! I just had a great visit to Liverpool and to Chester. Wonderful to see Welsh mountains in the distance from the city walls of Chester.
  • Feb 24, 2024
  • 7:31 AM All deaths in the period when Lucy was fully qualified and full time (with very much overtime) at CoCH, and 15 non-fatal collapses *selected by the gang of four* and exclusively at times when Lucy was on duty. How much of the time do you suppose she was in the ward? “Since the start of our enquiries and, as the information gathering process has continued, the scope of the investigation has now widened. We are now currently investigating the deaths of 17 babies and 15 non-fatal collapses between the period of March 2015 and July 2016” https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/16329278.healthcare-worker-countess-chester-hospital-arrested-suspicion-murdering-eight-babies/
  • 8:46 AM Interestingly in this case a judge blames previous judges https://www.judiciaryni.uk/sites/judiciary/files/decisions/Re%20A%20and%20B%20(Children%20Injury%20Proof%20Suspicion%20Speculation).pdf. The root of the problem is lack of understanding of science of judges and barristers and police. They ask scientists and experts and doctors questions which those persons should not be asked, because those experts are not supposed to judge, not supposed to give their opinion given *everything* they know. This is almost impossible for a doctor who, in his or her practice, does have to judge all the time! 2015 NIFam 14judiciaryni.uk1 Neutral Citation No. [2015] NIFam 14 Ref: OHA9745 Judgment: approved by the Court for handing down Delivered: 23/09/2015 (subject to ed…
  • Jul 7, 2024
  • 9:25 AM Hi Dewi, maybe it’s time we had a chat? I don’t want to blame you. I blame NHS underfunding. Really bad police work, “experts” who don’t follow the rules (and apparently don’t know the relevant science either). The jury system, the contempt of court rules, a biased judge, a weak defence. The farce of her appeal being rejected but the CPS appeal accepted. The CCRC is utterly unfit for purpose and the next stage is going to take five to ten years. This certainly is the biggest miscarriage of justice since those big famous ones which led to the setting up of the CCRC. Of course in public you will presumably, for a while, go on saying you believe Lucy is guilty. I know all about obstinacy! Anyway: my suggestion is we do a Zoom chat, not recorded, Chatham house rules for just us two. Clear the air. I’ll tell you some things you don’t know yet, and vice versa. Win win.
  • Jul 8, 2024
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 10:42 AM
  • 10:42 AM Currently getting over Covid, so back to normal next week.
    Afraid I don’t agree with you re the verdict. Letby was as guilty as they come. And to date, I’ve not seen a single comment from a suitably qualified person or institution that offers a reasoned defence. As for social media – best to give it a big ignoral. CCRC?
    As a witness of course one has to work within the system, but recognise its limitations.
    As for other cases, I expect that the police are investigating them. They involve displacement of breathing tubes for no apparent reason. And of course Lucy Letby was the nurse looking after the baby at the time. I’m not in touch with the police or the investigation any longer, so it will be interesting to find the outcome. My hunch is that there are quite a lot of other cases out there.
    [Interesting that since she was suspended in July 2016 (and I knew nothing about that before the trial) there have been few deaths at Chester apparently, and no ‘suspicious’ events.]
  • Jul 25, 2024
  • Richard Gill sent the following message at 7:27 PM 
  • 7:27 PM You would say that, wouldn’t you. Sorry, you are going to end up on the wrong side of history. “No apparent reason” does not equal “murder”. There are plenty of reasons breathing tubes get displaced. A person who gives expert evidence must be completely neutral and mention alternative explanations and margins of error. They must be fully qualified too. I’m sorry, but you are going to be in deep trouble.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 8:07 PM
  • 8:07 PM Richard. Just asking.
    Have you seen the clinical records of the babies? Have you seen / read the statements of the local medics and nurses? Have you read the statements of the parents? Were you at the trial? Does your medical experience extend beyond knowing which side of the bandaid you put on the wound?
    Cheshire Police are reviewing the notes of all babies at Chester, with the aid of an experienced neonatologist – I’m not involved and unaware of the findings. Don’t know if they are employing a statistician.
    So, Richard. Stick to your opinion. I’m still waiting for your evidence. But, for the record. None of my reports was based on “statistics”. It was based on Evidence. Look up its meaning. Her arrest, her charging, her guilty verdict had nothing to do with “statistics”. It was based on the Evidence of 6 independent experienced doctors, and the evidence of numerous local nurses and doctors. Evidence dear boy, Evidence!
    As for the Defence. It was their decision not to call evidence from independent clinicians and pathologists. Why do you think that was? Apart from the local plumber of course. Does one therefore assume that they consider your opinion less useful than that of a local plumber.
    Finally. Please do NOT make accusations about my evidence, or alleging that my evidence is not impartial. Half of my reports in criminal cases are at the request of the Defence. My most recent report for the Defence, just a few weeks ago, led to the Prosecution withdrawing the allegations within 2 hours of the opening of the trial.
    As for breathing tubes getting displaced for a number of reasons. For once you are correct. If you had listened to my evidence you would have known that I did not allege deliberate displacement of a breathing tube in any of the cases where I gave evidence.
    So, I’ll stick with the facts. Endorsed so far by judge and jury, Appeal Judge and 3 Appeal Court Judges. Not too bad I suppose.
    I look forward to your answers to my questions. I’m sorry if the facts (that word Evidence once more) get in the way of your opinion. But there you are. That’s a problem for you to address.
    Don’t see much point in engaging in a continuing dialogue. But thought that I should respond once.
  • Jul 26, 2024
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 11:08 AM
  • 11:08 AM Thanks. I hope you will keep your mind open to new evidence as it comes to light, like a real scientist always does. I hope you will also bear in mind the growing criticism against our judges and courts. UK criminal justice is just as broken as the NHS. I too stick to the facts. The fact is that Brearey and Jayaram ran to the police when they realised that they were in deep shit due to the RCPCH findings. The fact is that you violated the duty of a scientific expert, but of course, as you said, you are not really. a scientist.
  • 11:11 AM PS thanks for keeping the line of contact open! I still think that you have a fantastic opportunity to display wisdom and integrity. Do not let yourself be led by pride and vanity. Read the RSS report with great care. I talk to enough doctors who are better qualified than you to interpret those clinical notes, and many of them have access to those notes now. The arguments of appeal judges just show what big fools those people are. Also puffed up with vanity.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following message at 2:31 PM
  • 2:31 PM Not seen the RSS report! You are welcome to send it, or send me the link. But as I said, my evidence had nothing to do with statistics.
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 4:07 PM
  • 4:07 PM https://rss.org.uk/news-publication/news-publications/2022/section-group-reports/rss-publishes-report-on-dealing-with-uncertainty-i/. This was two years in the writing. Two of the five authors are lawyers RSS publishes report on dealing with uncertainty in medical “murder” casesrss.org.uk
  • 4:13 PM The defence didn’t understand medicine, didn’t understand science, didn’t understand statistics. Yeah – lawyers. Defence scored an own-goal by not disputing the interpretation of the immunoassay results. I just talked to a prominent UK professor of paediatrics. I asked him what he thought about the insulin? He basically said it was just bollocks and he explained why. This means that the evidence of Hindmarsh, Milan and Wark was just bollocks too. It may take 10 years, knowing UK criminal justice, but Lucy is going to walk free, you mark my words. Cheshire Constabulary have made enormous fools of themselves, costing the UK taxpayer millions, and by digging themselves in they are only making the debacle for themselves worse.
  • Dewi Evans sent the following messages at 4:54 PM
  • 4:54 PM Who’s this professor of paediatrics Richard?
  • 4:55 PM I’ll read the 64 page report over the weekend.
  • Jul 27, 2024
  • Richard Gill sent the following messages at 6:18 AM
  • 6:18 AM I can’t tell you that professor’s name, sorry. Enjoy your weekend! Let me know if you have any questions about the report. It went pre-trial to defence, to prosecution, and in fact to all concerned parties. The man from the CPS said to me (at a pre-publication try out at the Newton Institute in Cambridge) “we are not using any statistics in the Letby case. They only makes people confused”. The defence too just did not understand the statistical issues, which are issues of scientific research methodology. And of forensic scientific investigation methodology. They got comprehensive advice from a very competent statistician but did not understand a word of it.
  • 6:23 AM Sarrita Adams and I sent her medical analyses to the court during the trial, as an amicus brief. It was intercepted by Cheshire Police who sent Dutch police to my door in the night to deliver an intimidating letter. It threatened arrest next time I visited UK, two years in jail, and the cost of re-running the whole trial. The witch-burning mob doxed by mother’s address in a care home in Marlow, Bucks, and planned a demonstration outside. My Mother was 97. They also disrupted a lecture I gave at Liverpool University. The Mirror wrote that I was a sick and deluded conspiracy theorist and that I was attempting to corrupt the youth of England at the university, so the university authorities were evil too. Yep. All in a day’s work when you stand up against a witch hunt. Just so you know you are not the only guy getting publicly attacked in the media.
  • 5:47 PM A friend – professor of mathematics – recently asked me: “I can’t understand why medical experts seem to often be so dishonest”. Here is my answer: “They are not scientists. They are trained to be rapid judges and executioners. That’s one thing. The other thing is the medical hierarchy, and clan forming. The paediatricians are more concerned with the paediatricians than with their patients. The youngest and least paid always have to get the blame to protect the reputation and earning power of the older and most highly paid.” These are unfortunately easily verifiable true facts! Think of all those who kept on supporting Prof Sir Roy Meadow. Maybe he was a good children’s doctor. He was however a lousy statistician and a lousy psychologist and this caused enormous disasters. No doubt he was a charming and amicable man. I always invoke Hanlon’s razor. Stupidity is a more likely cause of despicable behaviour than malice.
  • 9:12 AM Here’s a name for you. Dr Svilena Dimitrova, NHS consultant neonatologist. Neonatologists against the paediatricians? CoCH had no neonatologist. Your friend well-known bully Dr Stephen Brearey “had an interest in neonatology” but was not a neonatologist. RCPCH (paediatricians!) told CoCH to recruit a neonatologist immediately.
  •  9:14 AM I’m not saying it’s all your fault. Police lie and cheat. This has been proven again and again. Cheshire Constabulary have an especially bad reputation in this respect. I think you should cut all links with the bad guys and change sides as fast as possible, if only to save your own skin.
  • 9:16 AM The momentum is growing. The Lucy Letby case is the biggest miscarriage of justice in the UK since the Guildford 4 and the Liverpool 6 (or were they 7 or were the numbers the other way round?). Just like the Lucia de Berk case in the Netherlands. The two cases are carbon copies of one another, but things panned out much worse in every respect in the UK. Utterly failed NHS, utterly failed CJS. Appalling gutter press. You should give an interview to a quality newspaper for a change.
  • Sep 13, 2024
  • 7:07 PM Intelligent life outside the M25: what do you think of me then?
  • 7:11 PM Babies do just suddenly drop dead. The Lucia de Berk case made that clear.
  • 7:17 PM Unexplained and unexpected actually does happen all the time.
  • 7:24 PM How did you exclude infection?
  • 7:38 PM There is not one unrecordable explanation of a low C-peptide level. One of the explanations is that it is too high!!!!
  • 7:43 PM What about the hook effect?
  • Sep 24, 2024
  • 4:30 PM And could we discuss the meaning of “accuracy” and “reliability” of immunoassays to determine insulin and C-peptide concentrations? How about specificity and sensitivity? Statistical concepts, I know. Would you be interested in a public debate? Online? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificitySensitivity and specificity – Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
  • Oct 1, 2024
  • 9:37 AM Hi Dewi, yet again, I want to suggest you change sides! Become a hero. I know you do have the guts to do it, you are not a scared little man. I hope you’ve now studied Marks and Wark (2013) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23751444/. It has a great summary of recommendations at the end. You see, Lucy Letby is innocent, 100% (ie, 99.99% certain, at least). Shall I show you the calculation? Science thrives on the clash of theories. As Niels Bohr once said “now we have a contradiction, at last we can make progress”. I honestly wish you well and know you are a good guy at heart. Forensic aspects of insulin – PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  • 9:45 AM This is also worth re-reading. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/15580088_Practical_concerns_about_the_diagnosis_of_Munchausen_syndrome_by_proxy(PDF) Practical concerns about the diagnosis of Munchausen syndrome by proxyresearchgate.net
  • Oct 2, 2024
  • 11:28 PM So you made a nice start, changing your expert medical opinion on three cases! But you are still convinced Lucy Letby was responsible. Surely that can only be by a statistical argument? But where are your statistical calculations and statistical qualifications? As far as I know neither police nor prosecution used testimony from a statistician. Lucy was often present at unpleasant events, but she worked the most hours of any nurse on that unit, and eagerly took the hardest shifts. Lucy’s defence team let her down badly, the judge was disgustingly biased. The whole disaster was not your fault. NHS managers and lawyers have a lot to answer for. Many reforms are needed. But they can only come if the system admits its failings.
  • 11:32 PM I offered my services to defence, prosecution, and to the court. But no one wanted to know. Cheshire constabulary threatened me and sent Dutch police to my door in the night, to deliver a letter in person which I’d already received by email. Very intimidating. They needed legal proof I’d received their warning.

What went wrong with the NHS went badly wrong at CoCH and it’s not a coincidence

I just recently became aware of a deep connection between Countess of Chester hospital and radical restructuring of the NHS in the early 90’s, which brought in new layers of bureaucracy and internal competition. Don’t coordinate and distribute. Instead, let hospitals compete, survival of the fittest, dynamic leadership,and innovation! We’ll end up with better health care for less money.

The connection is Sir Duncan Nichol, former chairman of the Countess of Chester hospital trust. That’s a higher management level than the hospital executive board. Side effect of the innovations was more managers with even bigger top salaries. But Nichol is not just any manager. He’s a former NHS chief-executive, “part tycoon, part mandarin”. Read all about Sir Duncan’s innovations here: https://www.managementtoday.co.uk/uk-profile-sir-duncan-nichol-nhs-chief-executive/article/409550

Source of the table: https://www.coch.nhs.uk/media/204393/BOD-March-2015.pdf, https://www.coch.nhs.uk/corporate-information/board-of-directors/board-of-directors-meeting-packs/archive.aspx. Sorry for all the misprints. CoCH management and more generally NHS management produced expensive glossy annual reports and other publicity material but it seems nobody ever bothered to check the text for spelling errors.

Here are some more quotes from Management Today, emphasis added by myself.

“Nichol helped oversee the greatest shake-up in the health service since the war. Out went the old-style consensus management where low-grade administrators charged round trying to keep high-grade doctors happy; in came a whole raft of modern business nostrums: greater pressure on cost-efficiency and customer satisfaction, the introduction of ‘internal markets’, the separation of key functions like purchasing and service provision, and, of course, the increasing use of snappy titles like chief executive and general manager.”

“Some, still seething at the enforced changes, argue that you cannot apply market doctrines to the basic tenets of caring and curing. Others, especially those working in conventional businesses, remain unconvinced that any amount of fancy tinkering will change the nature of the beast. The last few years, they note, have still been dotted with high profile examples of cash squandering on a massive scale.”

Time for a new post … on insulin

I would recommend everyone interested in the Lucy Letby case to carefully study the 58 page appeal judgement – a board of three judges refused Lucy’s application to appeal. It is only 58 pages, it is well written and carefully argued… It is just built on heaps of false assumptions. What it says about the insulin evidence is particularly significant.

Three points specifically concern the insulin babies, babies F and L: points 14, 30 and 104 [and another on the evidence of Prof Hindmarsh, which I won’t go into right now.]  Here they are in italics; my underlining.

14. A proposed ground 4 (that the jury were wrongly directed on evidence relating to the persistence of insulin in the bloodstream) was withdrawn following the refusal of leave to appeal by the single judge. 

30. At trial, the integrity of the blood samples and reliability of the biochemical testing was challenged by Mr Myers. However, in her evidence at trial, the applicant [Lucy Letby!] admitted that both babies had been poisoned by insulin, but denied that she was the poisoner. The prosecution relied upon the unlikelihood of there being two poisoners at work on the unit. As the judge expressed it shortly before the jury retired to consider their verdicts: “If you are sure that two of the babies…had Actrapid, manufactured insulin, inserted into the infusion bag that were set up for them 8 months apart in August 2015 and April 2016 respectively, and you are sure that that was done deliberately, you then have to consider whether that may have been a coincidence, two different people independently acting in that way or were they the acts of the one person and, if so, who.”

104. The prosecution made some general points to rebut the allegations of bias and unreliability, including that almost every opinion given by Dr Evans was corroborated by another expert. In addition, it was pointed out that Dr Evans was the person who had identified that two of the babies had been poisoned by insulin (Baby F and Baby L). This was a matter which had eluded the treating medics and went to prove that someone was committing serious offences against babies in the unit; and it was particularly important independent evidence, bolstering Dr Evans’ credibility and reliability. Further, when Dr Evans reached his conclusions, he did so without knowing about other circumstantial evidence relied on by the prosecution in establishing guilt, including the applicant’s Facebook searches, the shift pattern evidence, and the “confession” in the note recovered from the applicant’s home on 3 July 2018

Richard’s comment on point 30: the applicant was told during the trial that it had been proven that two babies had been poisoned. Her reply was not that she admitted this fact, it was more like “well if you say it is proven it must be true. But I didn’t do it”. Notice that for the prosecution, six experts all say that this was true: Evans, Bohin, Hindmarsh, Milan, Wark; the hospital doctors had concurred (Gibbs, in particular). The defence had apparently not even looked for an expert on the insulin matter. They had raised problems about the reliability of the tests but these are ignored because Lucy herself agrees that the babies were poisoned with hospital insulin.

How can a young nurse agree or disagree with a deduction made by half a dozen senior medics that the immunoassay results proved deliberate insulin poisoning? All doctors and nurses have been taught in doctors’ or nurses’ school something about insulin metabolism and know that the ratio of insulin to C-peptide (after someone has been fasting for three hours) should be about 1 to 6. They are not taught anything about the forensic determination of deliberate insulin poisoning, which tells us that an anomalous ratio is a warning sign for something that might have been happened but it should be followed up with completely different tests which exclude a numerous sets of artefacts which can each also cause an anomalous ratio of immunoassays’ numbers. The test result comes back from the lab with a warning note printed in red with exactly this information. It was ignored by hospital doctors. The specialists weren’t called in and never told about it. The babies were nicely recovering from their hypoglycaemia and were rapidly transferred elsewhere.

Note that according to point 14 the defence had submitted and withdrawn a “ground for appeal” concerning the insulin. [I don’t know what it was, someone should find out!]. Note that the insulin is seen by all concerned as proof of presence of a murderer on the unit. The court of appeal sees it as ludicrous to suggest there are two murderers on the unit! They believe that the other evidence (air embolism etc etc) proves Lucy is a murderer. The insulin evidence shows someone tried to murder babies F and L. There can’t be two murderers. Therefore Lucy also tried to murder babies F and L.

The logic of the argument is impeccable. Just the premises of the argument are wrong.

These points do show the utter incompetence of the defence team. 

One of the prosecution experts (Gwen Wark) has even published a paper Marks and Wark (2013) with a concluding list of recommendations which state that the immunoassay only suggests a possibility; in order to prove it other tests must be done. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23751444/ They were not done. No sample was saved so they never can be done. Both babies F and L are alive and well to this day though one has cerebral palsy … linked to problems experienced during birth.

At the trial Dr. Wark confirmed the other experts’ claim that insulin poisoning had been proven. How could she? What had she written in any written testimony provided pre trial to police or CPS? Richard Thomas (Lucy’s solicitor) says that the defence team can’t say whether or not any documents exist and whether or not they saw them. The jury is not shown any such documents.

People say “the jury was given so much more, information…”. That is quite simply not true. The jury in a UK criminal trial hears what is said and it observes the body language. That’s all. It does not receive copies of written testimony of scientific experts. (This is a consequence of “open justice” with a trial by a jury of your peers).

What was the fifth ground in the original application for an appeal? The one which a single judge scrapped and the defence team then scrapped too?

Maybe some journalist should chase after that. I’m afraid the defence team is unlikely to tell us. They are not obliged to, and they can only do it if Lucy instructs them to do so. And nobody is able to talk to her.

Letter to the BMJ

Rapid response to:

John Launer: Thinking the unthinkable on Lucy Letby

BMJ 2023; 382 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p2197, published 26 September 2023, cite as: BMJ 2023;382:p2197

Dear Editor

I am a coauthor of the report of the Royal Statistical Society https://rss.org.uk/news-publication/news-publications/2022/section-group-reports/rss-publishes-report-on-dealing-with-uncertainty-i/. It is deeply distressing that the police investigation into the case of Lucy Letby and the subsequent trial made all of the mistakes in our book. The jury was never told how the police investigation arrived at that list of “suspicious” events and how it was further narrowed down to the list of charges. This is a case in which a target was painted around a suspect by investigators. We call it confirmation bias, in statistics. It is also often referred to as the Texas sharpshooter paradox.

Thanks to amateurs who report their work on Twitter and YouTube, we now know how the list of charges in the Lucy Letby case evolved. It is utterly scandalous that this history was not revealed to the court. Here is the broad picture. 

Doctors reported Lucy to the police, against the wishes of the hospital board.

They told the police the exact period she had been on the ward and gave them the files on all deaths in that period and on some of the incidents: namely, exactly and only those “arrests” at which Lucy had been present.

What qualifies as an incident, what is an arrest?

There is no medical category “arrest, resuscitation” under which such events are logged in hospital administration. Probably there were about five times as many such events when Lucy was not on duty, but nobody has ever looked. There is no medical definition of such an event. No formal criteria.

“Unexpected, unexplained, sudden” are also not defined in any formal way. Nor is “stable”.

Next the absolutely unqualified, long retired, paediatrician Dewi Evans, who has a business helping out in civil child custody cases, went through those medical files looking for anomalies about which he could fantasise a murder or murder attack. His ideas that milk was injected into the stomach or air into the veins were far fetched, and later not confirmed by any other evidence. On the contrary, the actual evidence certainly contradicts the idea that Lucy Letby actually attacked any child. He never gave alternative medical explanations, as would have been the obligation of a forensic scientist. All the deaths had had a post-mortem and a coroner’s report. Every single event on the charge sheet has absolutely normal explanation. Lucy was never seen doing anything wrong.

The medical experts for the prosecution merely confirmed Evans’ diagnosis, they also did not do the job of a forensic scientist.

The defence had no experts. They had brought in one paediatrician. But at the pre-trial hearing he said he wasn’t qualified in endocrinology, toxicology, etc etc etc. 

This was Texas sharpshooter, big time. Plus utterly incompetent defence. 

Richard Gill

Member of Royal Dutch Academy of Sciences

Past president of Dutch statistical society.

The post-it note

Is Lucy’s post-it note a confession? Whether you will see it as a confession or a cry of innocent anguish depends on whether *you* have a heart and a brain. If you read it carefully, you will see that Lucy does not say that she killed those babies. She says that *they said* she killed those babies. Yes, she does say she is evil. She thinks she is clearly a bad nurse who apparently couldn’t save those babies, despite her (possibly too energetic, and certainly not well supervised) attempts. More seriously, she had had an affair with an older married man, a doctor, who later dumped her and betrayed her. She spoke out about doctors’ mistakes and about the catastrophic hygienic circumstances in which she and her colleagues had to work. For two years, doctors had tried to have her taken off that ward, because she pissed them off. Her colleague nurses loved her for her forthrightness and lovely character. She is so sorry for the suffering she caused her parents and step-brothers. She is considering suicide. She has PTSD.

This deciphering of the note was created by https://x.com/chrisjclarkesq?s=21&t=1S47Jut6K2dqjKzr1sc-4A , known as Mycroft on ‘X’, that is the ‘X’ formerly known as Twitter.

How to lie with data

This spreadsheet was shown on TV both yesterday (Friday August 18, the day of the verdicts) and at the start of the trial of Lucy Letby. Apparently, Cheshire Constabulary find this absolutely damning evidence against Lucy. And indeed, many journalists seem to agree.

The 25 events are almost all of the events at which LL was present during the periods investigated. They are suspicious because she was under suspicion when the police started their investigations. Not surprisingly, most nurses are not present at many of these events. And of course, many nurses probably work far fewer hours than LL. Many are often on administrative duties.

The doctors on the ward are of course missing. Doctors were never investigated as suspects but from the start of police investigations apparently always believed to speak gospel truth. During cross-examination, during the trial, some of them have changed various parts of their stories. Of course, unlike Lucy, they do not lie, since they could never (under oath in court, or earlier, when being interviewed as witnesses by police) be saying untruths in order to deceive.

Back to the spreadsheet. When drawing conclusions from any data it is important to know how it was gathered. It is important to know what data is missing, but would be needed draw even the most preliminary and tentative inferences.

There was an NHS investigation into the raised rates of deaths and collapses at Countess of Chester Hospital (CoCH) in summer 2015 and summer 2016. It was published in 2017 by the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH). The investigation blamed the consultants for the appalling low standard of care, and the terrible situation regarding hygiene. The RCPCH investigators actually wrote that nurse Lucy Letby could not be associated with the events, but that passage was redacted out of the published report for privacy reasons. We know that already, consultants had presented their fears to hospital management. One of them (successful TV doctor and FaceBook influencer dr Ravi Jayaram) was on TV yesterday proudly telling the world that he had been vindicated. Management was inclined not to believe them, and did not act on them, but they certainly came to the ears of the RCPCH. On publication of the report, four consultants had had enough, and went to the police with their suspicions that LL was a murderer.

Thanks to FOI requests and statistical analysis by independent scientists, we now know that the rate of events (deaths and collapses) is just as much raised when Lucy is not on the ward as it is when she is on the ward. A lot of medical information (as well as the state of the drains at CoCH) points to a seasonal virus epidemic.

The elevated rate went back to normal after the hospital was down-graded (no longer accepting high risk patients), and when the drains were rebuilt, and when the senior consultant retired, all of which happened soon after the police investigation started. Incidentally, the rate of still-births and miscarriages show exactly the same pattern.

Lucy must certainly have been a witch in order to kill babies in the womb and even when she is far from the hospital.

Those familiar with miscarriages of justice involving serial killer nurses will be familiar with this police and prosecution tactic. Is it evil or is it just stupid? (cf. Hanlon’s razor). I think it is quite simply “learnt”. Police and prosecution learn what convinces jurors over the years, and that is why the same “mistakes” are made again and again. They work!

The Lucy Letby case

Newest Note: [14 May] And then Rachel Aviv’s splendid article in the New Yorker came out, here is the link: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/05/20/lucy-letby-was-found-guilty-of-killing-seven-babies-did-she-do-it. I think this really marks “the end of the beginning” to quote a famous British statesman. Amusingly, The New Yorker has kindly blocked people with UK based IP address from reading it online, in order to comply with current reporting restrictions. One must not interfere with UK criminal justice; the next trial of Lucy – for killing baby K – must not be influenced. Some links to internet archive copies of the article can be found here: https://mephitis.co/new-yorker-magazine-lucy-letby-bombshell/. Hopefully readers in the UK will be able to get over these hurdles and find out what a lot of people outside the UK have already known for a year.

New Note: [10 May 2024] By now this post is even more terribly incomplete. Fortunately, Lucy Letby has more supporters (and support is growing by the day, to judge by social media) and this has resulted in a two splendid websites each with many articles concerning many aspects of the case, and a podcast with a fantastic series of conversations about the trial, and a YouTube channel. Here are links to them:

https://www.lucyletby.press “Vaudeville: Junk science and the Trial of Lucy Letby” is a website run by a retired medical practitioner from Ireland calling himself James Egan. Its blog contains numerous articles. Today it seems to be offline, I hope it will be back soon … and two days later it is back with a different address: https://jameganx.notepin.co/. Clearly in the process of redesign of the website, as well as moving to a new URL.

https://mephitis.co is run by Peter Elston, whose “chimpinvestor” site was one of the first to criticise the prosecution case against Lucy Letby. Peter has moved articles about the Letby case on that site to this new one. “Mephitis mephitis” is the scientific name of the animal we all know as the skunk.

https://podcasts.apple.com/dk/podcast/we-need-to-talk-about-lucy-letby/id1736761161 is a podcast series in which Peter talks about the case with another retired doctor, Michael McConville.

Finally I want to recommend Mark Mayes’ YouTube channel https://www.youtube.com/@ThePersecutionofLucyLetby (“The Persecution of Lucy Letby”). I also highly recommend Ceri Morrice’s videos, such as this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFTSV_qh_Ik. And while I’m at it I’ll mention my own YouTube production (two hours, sorry): a scientific lecture focussing on the spreadsheet, the green post-it note, and the insulin evidence https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxmFLKTlim8 “A tale of two Lucy’s”. I need to update part of that talk since I have since realised that the police were given medical notes (selected by the consultant paediatricians) on 32 babies, not on 32 events. And I’ve also learnt a great deal more about insulin. I expect the next version will be a set of three one-hour lectures (or maybe four).

Note: [20 August 2023] This post is incomplete. It needs a prequel: the history of medical investigations into two “unexplained clusters” of deaths at the neonatal ward of the Countess of Chester Hospital. It needs many sequels: statistical evidence; how the cases were selected (the Texas sharpshooter paradox) and the origin of suspicions that a particular nurse might be a serial killer; the post-it note; the alleged insulin poisonings; the trouble with sewage backflow and the evidence of the plumber; the euthanasias. For the medical material, the site to visit is the magnificent https://rexvlucyletby2023.com/.

This is how the post originally started:

Lucy Letby, a young nurse, has been tried at Manchester Crown Court for 7 murders and 15 murder attempts on 17 newborn children in the neonatal ward at Countess of Chester Hospital, Chester, UK, in 2015 and 2016.

She was found:– Guilty of 7 counts of murder (against 7 babies)
– Guilty of 7 counts of attempted murder (against 6 babies)
– Not guilty on 2 counts of attempted murder (against 2 of the 6 babies she *was* found guilty of attempting to murder). No decision was reached on 6 counts of attempted murder against 6 different babies. However, 2 of those 6 she was also found guilty of a different count of attempted murder. [Thanks to the commenter who corrected my numbers.]

The prosecution dropped one further murder charge just before the trial started, on the instruction of the judge. Several groups of alleged murders and murder attempts concern the same child, or twin or triplet siblings. All but one child was born pre-term. Several of them, extremely pre-term.

I’m not saying that I know that Lucy Letby is innocent. As a scientist, I am saying that this case is a major miscarriage of justice. Lucy did not have a fair trial. The similarities with the famous case of Lucia de Berk in the Netherlands are deeply disturbing.

BTW [16 May 2024], I still don’t *know* that she is innocent but I am increasingly certain that she is.

The image below summarizes findings concerning the medical evidence. This was not my research. The graphic was given to me by a person who wishes to remain anonymous, in order to disseminate the research now fully documented on https://rexvlucyletby2023.com/, whose author and owner wishes to remain anonymous. Note that the defence has not called any expert witnesses at all (except for one person: the plumber). Possibly, they had not enough funds for this. Crowd-sourcing might be a smart way of getting the necessary work done for free, to be used at a subsequent appeal. That’s a dangerous tactic, and it seems to me that the defence has already taken a foolish step: they admitted that two babies received unauthorised doses of insulin, and their client was obliged to believe that too.

This blog post started in May 2023 as a first attempt by myself to blog about a case which I have been following for a long time. The information I report here was uncovered by others and is discussed on various internet fora. Links and sources are given below, some lead to yet more excellent sources. Everything here was communicated to the defence, but they declined to use it in court. Maybe they felt their hands were bound by pre-trial agreement between the trial parties as to what evidence would be brought to the attention of the jury, which witnesses, etc.

An extraordinary feature of UK criminal prosecution law is that if exculpatory evidence is in the possession of the defence, but not used in court, then it should not be used at a subsequent appeal, whether by the same defence team or a new one. This might explain why the defence team would not even inform their client of their knowledge of the existence of evidence which exonerated her. Even though, it is also against the law that they did not, as far as we know, disclose evidence which they had which was in her favour. The UK law on criminal court procedure is case law. New judges can always decide to depart from past judges’ rulings.

A very important issue is that the rules of use of expert evidence is that all expert evidence must be introduced before the trial starts. It is strictly forbidden to introduce new expert evidence once the trial is underway.

UK criminal trials are tightly scripted theatre. The jury is of course incommunicado, very close to its verdict, and I do not aim to influence the jury or their verdict. I aim to stimulate discussion of the case in advance of a likely appeal against a likely guilty verdict. I wish to support that small part of the UK population who are deeply concerned that this trial is going to end in an unjustified guilty verdict. Probably it will, but that will not be the end. So much information has come out in the 9 months of the trial so far, that a serious fight on behalf of Lucy Letby is now possible. Public opinion crystallised long ago against Lucy. It can be made fluid again, and maybe it can even be reversed, and this is what must happen if she is to get a fair re-trial.

As a concerned scientist who perceives a miscarriage of justice in the making, I attempted to communicate information not only to the defence but also to the prosecution, to the judge (via the clerk of the court), and to the Director of Public Prosecutions. That was a Kafkaesque experience which I will write about on another occasion. Personally, I tend to think that Lucy is innocent. That was however not my reason for attempting to contact the authorities. As a scientist, it was manifestly clear to me that she was not getting a fair trial. Science was being abused. I tried to communicate with the appropriate authorities. I failed to get any response. Therefore I had to “go public”.

Here is a short list of key medical/scientific issues, originally copied from an early version of the incredible and amazing website https://rexvlucyletby2023.com/, with occasional slight rephrasing and some small, hopefully correct, additions by myself. That site presents full scientific documentation and argumentation for all of the claims made there.

  1. Air embolism cannot be determined by imaging, and can only be determined soon after death, and requires the extraction of air from the circulatory system, and analysis of the composition of the air using gas chromatography.
  2. The coroner found a cause of death in 5 out of 7 of the alleged murder cases. Two of them appeared to be, in part, related to aggressive CPR, two appeared to be due to undiagnosed hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and myocarditis, one of the infants received no autopsy, and the other infant was determined to have died due to prematurity. It is highly unusual for the cause of death to be altered years after the fact and using methodology that is not supported by the coroner’s office.
  3. The two claims of insulin poisoning are not supported by the testing conducted, and the infants (who are still alive and well) did not have dangerously low or dangerously high blood glucose levels for any period of time. There are many physiological reasons that could explain their low blood glucose during the whole period. In one of the two cases, assumptions are being made on the basis of one test taken at a single time point, clearly inconsistent with the other medical readings, and contravening the manufacturer’s own instructions for use (see image below). The report detailing the conclusions from that single test violates the code of practice of the forensic science regulator. Moreover, it appears that some numerical error has been made in the necessary calculation, resulting in an outcome which is physiologically impossible (or the person responsible did not know about the so-called “hook effect”). The mismatch between C-peptide and insulin concentration does not prove that the excess insulin found must have been synthetic insulin. There are many other biological explanations for a mismatch. No testing was done to determine the origin of the insulin. Similarly, there are many innocent explanations for the detection of some insulin in a feeding bag.
  4. The air embolism hypothesis is confusing because it fails to explain why some children apparently perished and others did not, and it has not been supported by the minimal necessary measurements.
  5. In at least one case, Lucy is blamed with causing white matter brain injury. This claim is utterly dishonest. The infant who experienced this brain injury was born at 23 weeks gestation, and white matter brain injury is associated with such early births. Further, there is sufficient evidence that demonstrates that enterovirus and parechovirus infection has been linked to white matter brain injury in neonates, resulting in cerebral palsy.
  6. At the time of the collapses and deaths of the infants, enterovirus and parechovirus had been reported in other hospitals. There is a history of outbreaks of these viruses in neonatal wards in hospitals around the world. They especially harm preterm infants who do not yet have a functioning immune system. It is reported that many parents of the infants were concerned that their ward had a virus (as was Lucy) and that Dr Gibbs denied this was so. To date we have seen no evidence to show they did any viral testing, and if they did what the results were.

Then a fact pertaining to my own scientific competence.

Both prosecution and defence were warned long ago about the statistical issues in such cases. Both have responded that they are not going to use any statistics. They are also not using the services of any statistician. Seems the RSS report https://rss.org.uk/news-publication/news-publications/2022/section-group-reports/rss-publishes-report-on-dealing-with-uncertainty-i/ has had the opposite effect to that intended. Amusingly, the same thing happened in the case of Lucia de Berk. At the appeal the prosecution stopped using statistics. She was convicted solely on the grounds of “irrefutable medical scientific evidence”. (Here, I’m quoting from the words both spoken by the judges and written down on the first page of their > 100 page report of the reasons and reasoning which had led to their unshakable conviction that Lucia de Berk was guilty. The longest judge’s summing up in Dutch legal history). I was one of the five coauthors of the RSS report. We were a “task force”, formally commissioned by the “Statistics and the Law” section of the society. I consider it the most important scientific work of my career. It took us two years to put together. We started the work in 2020; we had seen the Lucy Letby trial on the horizon since 2017 when police investigations started and the suspect being investigated was already common knowledge.

The UK does not have anything like that because a jury of ordinary folk are the ones who (legally) determine guilt or innocence. This is a clever device which makes fighting a conviction very difficult; no one can know what arguments the jury had in their mind, no one knows what, if anything, was the key fact that convinced them of guilt. Ordinary people are convinced by what seems to be a smoking gun, they then see all the other evidence through a filter. This is called “confirmation bias”. In the Lucy Letby case, the smoking gun was probably the post-it note, and the insulin then seems to clinch the matter. The prosecution cross-examination convinces those who already believe Lucy is guilty that she moreover is constantly lying. More on all this in later posts, I hope.

Back to the insulin. Here are the instructions on the insulin testing kit used for the trial, taken from this website http://pathlabs.rlbuht.nhs.uk/ccfram.htm, the actual file is http://pathlabs.rlbuht.nhs.uk/insulin.pdf. Notice the warning printed in red. Yes, it was printed in red, that was not something I changed later. (All this is not my discovery; the person who uncovered these facts wishes to remain anonymous).

The toxicological evidence used in the trial violates the code of practice of the UK’s Forensic Science Regulator (see link below). It should have been deemed inadmissible. Instead, the defence has not disputed it, and thereby obliged their own client Lucy to agree that there must have been a killer on the ward. The jury are instructed to believe that two babies were given insulin without authorization, endangering their lives. (The two babies in question are still very much alive, to this day. Probably now at primary school.)

The defence stated to me that they cannot inform Lucy of the alternative analysis of the insulin question. It appears to me that this violates their own code of practice. Do they feel bound by the weird rules of UK’s criminal prosecution practice? Their client, Lucy Letby, is herself essentially merely a piece of evidence, seized by the police from what they believe is a scene of crime. No one may tamper with it during the duration of her own trial, which is lasting 10 months! I think this constitutes an appalling violation of basic human rights. The UK laws on contempt of court are meant to guarantee a fair trial. But in the case of a 10-month trial on 22 charges of murder and attempted murder, they are guaranteeing an unfair trial.

Lucy’s solicitor refused to pass on a friendly personal letter of support to Lucy or to her parents because she had not instructed him to do so. Should one laugh or cry about that excuse? I have the impression that he is not very bright and that he may have been convinced she is guilty. If so, I hope he is changing his mind. In the UK, the solicitor does all the legwork and communication between the client and the defence team. The barrister does the cross-examinations and the court theatrics, but probably never builds up a personal relationship with his client. Lucy has been all this time prison, in pre-trial detention, far from Manchester or Hereford. This might explain the extraordinarily weak defence which has been put up so far. But it might be deliberate.

One must take into account the fact that funding for legal support is meagre. The prosecution has been working on the case for 6 or so years, with unlimited resources. The defence has had a relatively very short time, with very limited resources. Probably the solicitor and the barrister already put in many more hours than they are paid for. There are no funds for expensive scientific witnesses. It is very possible that the defence team well understands that they cannot put up a serious defence during the 9 to 10 months of the trial, but that precisely this time period, with a huge number of revelations being made outside the trial, material for a serious defence during an appeal has been “crowd-sourced”. It seems to me that this mass of high-quality independent scientific work provides plenty of grounds for an appeal, in the case that the jury hands down a guilty verdict.

Some links:

Sarrita Adams’ Science on Trial website

scienceontrial.com

Formerly: https://rexvlucyletby2023.com/


Scott McLachlan’s Law Health and Tech blog

LL Part 0: Scepticism in Action: Reflections on evidence presented in the Lucy Letby trial. https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/scepticism-in-action

LL Part 1: Hospital Wastewater https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-1-hospital-wastewater

LL Part 2: An ‘Association’ https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-2-an-association

LL Part 3: Death already lived in the NICU Environment, https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-3-death-already-lived-in

LL Part 4: Outbreak in a New NICU: Build it and the pathogens will come…https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-4-outbreak-in-a-new-nicu

LL Part 5: The Demise of Child A https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-5-the-demise-of-child-a

LL Part 6: The Incredible Dr Dewi Evans https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-6-the-incredible-dr-dewi

LL Part 7: The Demise of Child C. https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-7-the-demise-of-child-c

LL Part 8: The Death of Child D. Had she been left or resumed on CPAP, she might still be alive today. https://lawhealthandtech.substack.com/p/ll-part-8-the-death-of-child-d


Peter Elston’s “Chimpinvestor” blog

Do Statistics Prove Accused Nurse Lucy Letby Innocent? https://www.chimpinvestor.com/post/do-statistics-prove-accused-nurse-lucy-letby-innocent This splendid and comprehensive blog post also has a large list of links to reports and data sets. Yet more data analysis can and should be done. This site gives anyone who wants to a quick-start. And after that, two more outstanding posts…

https://www.chimpinvestor.com/post/more-remarkable-statistics-in-the-lucy-letby-case

https://www.chimpinvestor.com/post/the-travesty-of-the-lucy-letby-verdicts


Data obtained from FOI requests

FOI requests provided some fantastic data sets https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/neonatal_deaths_and_fois#incoming-1255362 see especially https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/521287/response/1265224/attach/2/FOI%204568×1.xlsx?cookie_passthrough=1


How forensic science should be reported in court

Forensic Science Regulator: statutory code of practice https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/statutory-code-of-practice-for-forensic-science-activities


One of numerous enterovirus and parechovirus epidemics in neonatal wards

Cluster of human parechovirus infections as the predominant cause of sepsis in neonates and infants, Leicester, United Kingdom, 8 May to 2 August 2016 https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.34.30326


Someone commissioned a pretrial statistical and risk analysis – results not used in the trial

Lucy Letby Trial, Statistical and Risk Analysis Expert Input. Who commissioned this analysis, and what did it yield? (I can give you the answer after the verdict has come out). https://www.oldfieldconsultancy.co.uk/lucy-letby-trial-statistical-and-risk-analysis-expert-input/


The RSS (statistics and law section) report – not used in the trial

Royal Statistical Society: “Healthcare serial killer or coincidence?
Statistical issues in investigation of suspected medical misconduct” by the RSS Statistics and the Law Section, September 2022 https://rss.org.uk/news-publication/news-publications/2022/section-group-reports/rss-publishes-report-on-dealing-with-uncertainty-i/

At a pre-publication meeting of stake-holders held to gain feedback on our report, a senior West Midlands police inspector told me “we are not using statistics because they only make people confused”. Lucy’s sollicitor and barrister knew well in advance of our report, were even given names of excellent UK experts whom they could consult, but did not bother to contact one of them. No statistics in our courts please, we are British! Yet the UK has the best applied statisticians and epidemiologists in the world.


Article in “Science” about my work on serial killer nurses

Unlucky Numbers: Richard Gill is fighting the shoddy statistics that put nurses in prison for serial murder. Science, Vol 379, Issue 6629, 2022. https://www.science.org/content/article/unlucky-numbers-fighting-murder-convictions-rest-shoddy-stats


Two subreddits on the Lucy Letby case

https://www.reddit.com/r/scienceLucyLetby/ (the Lucy Letby Science subreddit)

https://www.reddit.com/r/lucyletby/ (general)


Medical Ethics

John Gibbs, recently retired Consultant Paediatrician at the Countess of Chester
Hospital, defined Medical Ethics as “Playing God with Life and Death decisions.”
See article “Medical Ethics” on page 6 of The Messenger, Monthly Newsletter of St Michael’s, Plas Newton, Chester) – reporting on talk by Dr John Gibbs, retiring paediatrician at CoCH. https://stmichaelschester.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Messenger-April-2020.pdf. Audio: https://stmichaelschester.com/sermons/encounter-medical-ethics/


The state of forensic science in the UK

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001k7vt?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile “The UK’s forensic science used to be considered the gold standard, but no longer. The risk of miscarriages of justice is growing. And now a new Westminster Commission is trying to find out what went wrong. Joshua talks to its co-chair, leading forensic scientist Dr Angela Gallop CBE, and to criminal defence barrister Katy Thorne KC.”


Criminal Procedure Rules and Criminal Practice Directions

Revised rules came out earlier this year, so maybe they do not apply to a trial which started earlier. Still, they express what the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales presently wants to promote. https://www.judiciary.uk/guidance-and-resources/message-from-lord-burnett-lord-chief-justice-of-england-and-wales-new-criminal-practice-directions-2023/ . See especially Section 7 of his “Criminal Practice Directions (2023)” https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Criminal-Practice-Directions-2023-1-3.pdf


New expert evidence cannot be admitted once a trial is in progress

“The courts have indicated that they are prepared to refuse leave to the Defence to call expert evidence where they have failed to comply with CrimPR; for example by serving reports late in the proceedings, which raise new issues (Writtle v DPP [2009] EWHC 236). See also: R v Ensor [2010] 1 Cr. App. R.18 and Reed, Reed & Garmson[2009] EWCA Crim. 2698″. This quote comes from https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/expert-evidence. Note, a judge is always allowed to break with precedence. The rule is not actually a permanent rule, it is merely a description of current practice. Current practice evolves when and if a new judge sees fit to break with precedence. Obviously, he would have to come up with good legal reasons why he believes he has to do that. It’s his prerogative, his free choice. That’s the essence of case law, aka common law.

CBS Statistieken, uitkeringsaffaire, uithuisplaatsingen

Deze saga zet zich voort met een nieuwe publicatie van het CBS, https://www.cbs.nl/nl-nl/achtergrond/2023/05/onzekerheidsmarges-onderzoek-toeslagenaffaire-en-jeugdbescherming. Nou ja, het kwam uit anderhalf maand geleden. Ik was met andere dingen bezig …

Hierbij een eerste indruk. Er worden nu betrouwbaarheidsintervallen bepaald en men ziet meteen dat de statistische onzekerheid enorm is. Natuurlijk, worden deze berekeningen gebaseerd op statistische veronderstellingen, en die zijn altijd betwistbaar. Maar op zijn minst kunnen ze geinterpreteerd worden op een pure beschrijvend-data manier als een gevoeligheids analyse. Een brede interval laat zien dat als de data een klein beetje anders was, het antwoord totaal anders zou zijn geweest. We weten zo wie zo dat er allerlei foutbronnen zijn; we weten dat de gegevens in de data bestanden van rijksinstellingen heel ver kunnen afliggen van de ervaringen van de burgers; dat ze afhangen van allerlei definities en afspraken die hun oorsprong hebben in bureaucratische administraties.

Een belangrijke resultaat is het plaatje hieronder, waarbij statistische onzekerheidsmarges toegevoegd zijn aan een plaatje uit de eerste (en omstreden) CBS rapport. Figuur 6.1.1.

Ik heb de “kleine letters” en de “nog kleinere kleine letters” meegenomen, niet om te lezen, maar om te laten zien dat er een hele technisch verhaal bijhoort.

De eerste indruk is dat het lijntje in het midden ongeveer plat is. Dus: de nare ingreep (gedupeerd zijn) in jaar “nul” geen sterke effect heeft. Men ziet over meerdere jaren een lichte toename bij dezelfde 4000 gezinnen van maatregelen van jeugdbescherming wat, zo te zien, beste toevallig had kunnen zijn. De hypothese van “geen impact” kan niet verworpen worden op grond van deze cijfers.

Maar, dat is niet de enige mogelijke uitleg van het plaatje, en die is net zo min te verwerpen. Dat hobbeltje in de grafiek zou ook “echt” kunnen zijn, en bovendien veroorzaakt door de klap wat de belastingdienst in “jaar nul” uitdeelde. Het ziet eruit als een stijging van een half procent per jaar, over meerdere jaren. De meest aannemelijke schatting is dat 20 tot 30 (of zelfs meer) echte dubbele slachtoffers zijn; dubbele slachtoffers in de zin dat gedupeerd zijn door de uitkeringsschandaal werkelijk leidde tot een uithuisplaatsing wat anders niet zou zijn gebeurd.

Het echte effect is gedempt en uitgesmeerd door alle tekortkomingen van het onderzoek. De conclusie moet zijn: het zijn zeker tientallen en mogelijk zelfs honderd.

Overigens, zou ik graag een keer een extra cijfer willen hebben waardoor ik de statistische onzekerheid in het verschil in hoogte van deze twee waardes (blaue en groen) zou kunnen evalueren.

Er zijn ruwweg 4000 gedupeerden en die zijn gepaard één op één met vergelijkbare niet-gedupeerden. We hebben feitelijk te maken met rond de 4000 matched pairs. Het CBS weet van elk lid van elk paar of een jeugdbescherming actie plaatsvond. We hebben feitelijk 4000 waarnemingen van paren, elk waarvan een van de vier waardes kan aannemen (0, 0), (0, 1), (1, 0), (1, 1); noem deze twee gevallen (x, y). Een “1” betekent uit een huisplaatsing (of iets dergelijks), een “0” betekent geen uithuisplaatsing. We zijn geinteresseerd in de gemiddelde van de x‘en minus de gemiddelde van de y‘s. Dat is hetzelfde als de gemiddelde van alle (x – y) waarden; elk ervan is gelijk aan –1, 0, of +1. Ik zou graag het 2×2 tabel willen zien van aantallen van elk van de vier mogelijke gesamenlijke uitkomsten (x, y). Ik zou de standaard afwijking willen uitrekenen van de (x – y) waarden. Dit zou ons inzicht geven in de mate van success van de matching: als het goed is, zouden we een positieve correlatie zien tussen de uitkomsten van de twee groepen. Een correlatie van +1 zou impliceren dat de uitkomst volledig bepaald is door de matching variabelen, dat zou betekenen: gedupeerd zijn maakte werkelijk niks uit. Kom’ns op, CBS!

%%footer%%